\RɖłڂꂽJ^h |
gɌAArWA\R Zɑق肵ĐEjƕȂ̂ŁȀ\RƂ̂̓CXkɑĂ̂ꂽ̂ƎvĂB ƂłȂAArWA\RipEAlbigensian CrusadejƂ̂1209NɂA1244NɃZM[iMontsegurj̒̕ɂR邪ח܂ł̔I߂ɂ킽đALXgْ̈[J^h̐lXAނlBʋsEB J^hƂ͂ǂvzْ[̂A[}@CmPeBEX3͂ǂăJ^hł悤Ƃ̂AArWA\R͒Nǂ̂悤ɂăJ^h|̂ǍJ^h͂ǂȂ̂B̓_ׂĂ݂̂ŁAǂ킸ɃVbt[hŏĂ݂B J^iEcathare pEcatharjƂ̂̓MVKatharosiȁAȁjɗRƂ̂BkC^AAtXɋ}ɍL܂AtX̃AriAlbijƂœɎx҂̂ŃArWAiAlbgeoisjhƂĂB Ar܂ޒtXт̓OhNƌĂꂽB̒nł́AktXŎgtXɔׂĂ胉eɋ߂tbB̌t̓INiocjƌĂꂽ̂ŁA̒nLangue-d'ocƂBȂ݂ɁAAr̒́A|X^[̐҂ƂĒmgD[[Y[gbN̐܂ꂽƂłB kɑ郍[k삪nCɗꍞނ肩琼ɍLnAɃJ^h̐M҂Aփ{h[܂őEYE~fB^͉ɃxWGAǓssJJb\kAgD[[YȂǁAArWA\RXɏPB~fB^͂̓sl[R̊Ԃʂ蔲ă{h[܂őB ̒n}ArWA\RWn悪킩B FEINJ^h_Ă 12lƂi10lƂ邪͂ǂjJ^ĥ߂̃ArWA\ŔA1209N6ɏWA[kɉĐiRBxWGiBeziersjA悻365LA721ɂ͒B ̒n}A}ZCE̒[ɂ邪AxWG͂^ɍsƂɂAnCƃsl[Rɂ͂܂ꂽBMIDI^͗sLƂʐ^̋L̂ŁAȂtX͋̕C𖡂Ă݂̂܂ꋻB \ŔȀZɑăJ^h̐M҂n悤ɗvBƂɁAJgbNM҂xWǴA݂ł̗vۂB722A\R͒ɍUߓAƂԂɒ̂BsEn܂B @́wƂĐsĂ[}@̓gAm[ɁARmu˂AJ^h̐M҂ƃJgbN̐M҂ǂČ̂ƁBAm[̓qXebNɓB uFEIiJ^hǂ́j_Ƃ猩Ăv ̐͒肩łȂA1l2̏ZEꂽƂB200lقǂ̃J^h̐M҂E߂ɁB1213NɏꂽArWA\RɂĂ̋L^ɂƁȀŹAJ^hM҂ł͕KȂ̂ɁAJ^hƂƂɎꂸɎEĂƂB̒̐lB́ACGXƃ}O_̃}AlƂƂMĂƂB傤ǁA722͐}Ai}O_j̓B xWG̋sĚA1209N81A\R̓I[h͉̒JJ\kiCarcassonnejɓBJJ\k͋łȏǓssŁAxWG̉\Ă瓦ẴJ^h̐lŖcĂB30߂Əǂň͂܂ꂽJJ\k̒́Aʂď\R̍U𗽂邾낤B lXREŸJJ\k̒̑SiA̎ʐ^ǂB REe̓앧OhbN XyC̖kAtXƂ̍ɈʒuÃAS̃yhQ̂߂ɃJJ\kɗBJJ\k̓gJxƂ̗̒nAAS̔쉺ɂB@gAm[͊łɒ₵Ayh͓{ăASɖ߂B \R͍UJnBAw֕ɏoĂ悤Ȑ킢̂낤BTrebuchetMangonneauȂǂ̓@gĂ̏闎BQlɁA̓̓@̃XPb`AɂĒuB Us̃JJ\k݂̎͐B̕⋋H₽ꂽǓsśATԌɍ~BJ^hM҂ی삵ĊeAgJxƂ̗̎AQT̃EWFR͗HARɎBJJ\kł͑sE͋NȂBJ^hM҂܂߂ďZ͕ꂽB ArWA\ŘR̃[_[̈lAVEhEtH[SJJ\kAArAxWGnт̗L邱ƂɂȂB̋RmB̑́A@̑̒nɋȂAktX֖߂B łƁAArWA\R̋NwiA킩͈͂ł܂Ƃ߂Ă݂B A@肪傫BJ^h̍l͌ɂڂ邪ÁAJgbN̎xzɑēs̈_ȒPɏqׂBJ^hɂA̐ē͈̂̐_ɂĐݏoꂽ̂ŁA͑P̐_ɑ̂Őn̐Ă~BA~邽߂ɎiՂ@KvƂȂBOm[VXIȔzB_ւ̒҂sKvƂĺA[}@MƂJgbÑnCA[L[ɂƂẮAɍB tX̔rIɉhA[}@ɂƂĂ͋CɓȂBOhbNńA܂[}@ʗpĂBɑāAktXł̓tNl̕łubNXETJvƂ@TB̓tX̐EЉI͋C̃TCgŕ`ʂĂ̂ŁAȉpB OhbO͐kƂ͈قȂAʈӎ̂Ȃn悾BMVAlAtFjLAlA_lACXkǂ炵Ă̂B_l͔Qǂ납A̎傩ocږ܂ꂽAiɂȂ҂܂łBK̈ႢقƂǂȂB_ẑ悤ȋJIKȂB͎R̂́B@̓[}@B{ӂ閯OBȕƏƁB[bpōłhnBꂪOhbN̂BV̒YKA̎EeExAԑRƂJgbN͎捞ޏpmȂBv́AB̏isꂪǂǂƐNHėĂƌƂ낤BCrusadeƂ`ʼn悤AƖ@CmPeBEX͍lɈႢȂB JJ\kUk邱Ƃ悻2NA1207NACmPeBEXJ^h̓gɖꂽAm[́A͂߂邽߁AVg[h̃sG[EhELXem[tXEgD[[Ỹ6̂ƂɑBOqAJJ\kō邱ƂɂȂAEWF3̏fɂB 6́A̗̖쒀Ă̓ɂȂȂƍlAςƃJ^hQۂBJXeBm[̓̔jvA1207N5ɁA͔jƂȂB 1208N1AJXeBm[ƃ̓voXōēxbBl荇̖ʂɏIBAJXeBm[͎̂ƂȂĔꂽB̑hqɈÎEꂽɈႢȂB@CmPeBEX3͓{苶AArWA\Rv̂BJ^hƋɁAJ^hi삷MłڂBD̓y͐̂҂ɗ^ƖꂽB xWGAJJ\kA~lxAeXAXƐ́AD𑱂ArWA\RgD[YɍU߂Ă͎̂Ԃ̖肾B J^h̋`|̕E͈̐_̑n ExgEG[ŔuKN̖Ovɂ̉fAԂOɊςAł̓J^hA{S~hA@hhȂǂْ̈[̂ƂoĂAƂEGbuTCgɏĂB̉f܂ςĂ݂ȂB āA12A13IɈْ[ƂꂽJ^hA{S~hA@hhȂǂ͂Ȃ苤ʂlĂB狳h̋ʓ_ŁALXgْ͈[ƂvfƂ͉H ܂APƈ̓_B_́A3Î͂߂ɃCl}jɂđnnꂽ}jɗRƌB}j͕A_ALXgȂǂꂱ̗vfĎ̋`nBꂽE@Ƃ邪Ảe̓J^h܂߂ɎcĂB J^h̓_ɂɒ[Ȃ̂牸₩Ȃ̂܂ł悤Av_́AlB̏ZތE̐_̑nƂBl̍isoulj́A_̑n̂̒Ɏ̗̂~]ɘf킳ĂB Ă錻̕E͊{IɈieviljȂ̂ƂAl̖̐ړI͂Ȃ낤B̑̂܂߂ĕEł邱ƂF邱ƁAĂ甲oVE̗ispiritǰɖ߂ƂłB ǂāAVE̗ɖ߂邱ƂôBnA֗~ACsłB𐴏ipurifyj邱ƁBOɐGꂽ悤ɁAJ^̌ꌹ̓MVAKatharosiȁAjłB̕EŁAo邾𐴂ۂAVE̗ƍꂷ邱Ƃɋ~B J^hɂ͌Vʉ߂PerfectiiSȎҁjƒʏ̐M҂łCredentes̋ʂBPerfectiɂȂׂɂ́AConsolamentumiԂ߂̋VHjƂ̐ŁAYLAEEHׂǍ₿A킢Ȃ𑗂˂ȂȂB PerfectiAケ̈̐E~BPerfecti̍͂̓̂AV̗̂Ƃɖ߂BPerfectiłȂ҂́A܂~Ȃ҂́A܂̈̕Eɖ߂Âɏh邱ƂɂȂB̕ӂ͕̗։vzB PerfectiEnduraiEsHjƂߍȋVsBHۂAQɎVłB _ntXlvzƁAV[kEFCiSimone WeiljxjŎ̂1943N8Aޏ̔N4ɔxj̐ffĂAHقƂǐۂȂƂbǂƂBޏ̓J^hɌX|Ă̂ŁAƔޏ̎EnduraiEsjȂBႦAޏ͎̂悤ɌĂB OhbN̐lBiJ^hj̐_̖{̓MVA̐_̂ƓBRA]B̑̂킳鎞s^SXIȒaށBAa\Ȃ̂͏Ȏғm̏ꍇB J^h̋`|_m̂ɋ͕KvȂ OAJ^ȟےƋ֗~`ɂĐGꂽAނɐĂ킯A̐M҂̏ꍇA̓NwOʂɉô͎OɂĂ炾BConsolamentumiԂ߂̋Vĵ͒ʏ펀o債ĂŁA܂ł͌ALYĐĂBA̕ȆB}邽߂ADƑقsꂽ悤łBɂẮA֎~ĂƂAeFĂƂBOɂGꂽȀ@ɑĂ͊eŁA_ltX̎ЉɍLĂB āAJ^hْ[ƂꂽRɖ߂낤BF̓_ŌE̎Yƍl邱Ƃ̈B̓́ADocetismiLXgjƂAJ^hȂǃOm[VXIȏ@h̍lB̓JgbN̎Oʈ̐̃hO}ɓěƂ܂ȂB LXgł́ACGXg̓̂AɂȂĎɁAĕƂhO}͔ے肳B̐Ȇ͈n̂łAP̐_̐EŎۂɂȂ蕜킯͂ȂB_͏ȗȂ̂ÂƂ͂ȂB܂CGXƂ̂͐lԂɌ[^邽߂̐_̎gҁA_̉ۂɉ߂ȂB LXg̃J^h͂A\˂Ȃǂł悭ApԂǂCGX̌ĝ̏ےƂĎgTNgiA`Ȃǂ̔ցj̋VȂB\˂Ȃւے肷J^hA͐hJgbNɂ͋ȂƂB JgbNɂƂĂɋȂƁBJ^h͈ll̐MɏduAƂ̈ʊK̕Kvے肵BJgbN̎łipurgatoryjƂƍߕiindulgencejƂ~̊TOےBAsĂJgbÑnCG[L[{ے肵lB ̓_͏dvB̖lBɂ͂ƑzłȂAuO͒nɗvƍꂽA[}@j傳ꂽ肷邱Ƃ́A̐̐lBɂƂĂ͎ʂhƂɈႢȂBA̋̃WbNSے肷ɂ͑ςȗECKvBȂ݂ɁAtXk̏ArWA\RɎQR̈́AQ邱Ƃɂč߂Ƃ̖@̖B JgbNÃJ^h̍lłɒڂƂ́AjɍsnĂƂƂB̂𖾓B J^h̒j N獡NɂĂ̑xXgZ[u_r`ER[hv́Al̂悤ȃLXgs܂߂đ̐lɁAJgbN̏}̗jɌă}O_̃}ÁuvĂꂽB JgbN̒jڂ͑Iȃ_ɗR̂낤Bi_Ɍ炸AIȎЉł͒jڂƂȂ̂낤BCjVA`uЉʔbĂB _̐TȂnLɞHAuȂ_́AyiA_}j̐oŐliA_j`ÂEEEl甲獜ŏグꂽv _̐Eł́AEC͒jEA_ʂႭAjɏ]҂ƂꂽAĵ獜瑢炽̂BƂđhꂽȀ@IV̏ł͉̖ȂB͒j̋CU炷ƂRŁAViS[Oi_̋jł̗q͒jʁX̕ōsBȂ͕vƑqɃg[[i̍ŏ̌=@̏j悤Ɋ߂邪AȂƖ͕KvȂƂꂽBv́AȂƂɎcAsɏođ̒jBmB͒mIɂ̓IɂjɗĂƂꂽB#1 ɑΌ́ALXg̊OT̒Ń}O_̃}A邢͏ʂɑyepĚtƂČĂB VEyeiÃ[}@ƂjނɌAu}ni}O_̃}Aj͎B̂Ƃ狎ق悢B͐ɒlȂłvig}X̕@114j#2 i}O_̃}AACGX̌ACGX̌tbjAhAu}AȂƌƁA͋~傪ȊȂƂƂ͐MȂBvyeɑAu~傪B̒mȂƂŁABďȂƌt킷ƎvH̏̌ƂMƂ̂H~͎B肠̏̂قƂ̂Hvi}A̕j#3 zŕĂABF萹̉߂Ă悢BipEuRglւ̎莆v1-11:3-15j[zŕ̂́A̐Eɍ߂C̒p̏ƂĂׂĂ̏ɉȂB܂AޏB͈ӎvȂ̂ŁA̓Vg̘f킳Ȃ悤ɂ邽߁AƍlꂽB]CGX̌p҂Ƃ݂ȂꂽyeɂẮA܂ʂ̋@ɂƔᔻAł̈p炩Ȃ悤ɁAye̓_̎ccCGX̐MkBނ̑bƂȂĊmJgbN_̒jڂcĂĂAsvc͂ȂB ɑāAJ^h͂Ώ@v̐삯B uKAōL܂{S~hƓli邢́A{S~heājAJ^hł͒j͂قڕB͋c̃[_[ɂȂꂽE҂ɂȂꂽBj̓̂̋ʂ͈_̈ɉ߂Ȃ̂A̋ʂłĐl̏̂͂B~ēV̗ɖ߂ɂ́A̋ʂ͈ӖƁAl̂낤B 11I13Iɂē앧ōL܂goh[ƃJ^h̊W錤҂ȂȂBVl̍i̒ł́AB͒j̖lł͂Ȃh̑ΏۂBJ^h̒jςeƂ̂BiƂAオႦΏq͏̗̎ԂƌAႦΎO}aq́ůvvBjɁA̎loƂA̎ЉÏB#4 #1@The Redemption of Eve by Jolene Edmunds Rockwood ihttp://home.uchicago.edu/~spackman/RedemptionofEve.pdfj #2@g}Xɂ镟@r䌣@iukЁA1994Nj #3@Beyond belief by Elaine Pagels iRandom House, 2003Njٖ #4@Bogomils, Cathars, Lollards and the High Social Position of Women during the Middle Ages by Georgi Vasilev ihttp://facta.junis.ni.ac.yu/facta/pas/pas2000/pas2000-02.pdfj ZM[ɏJ^h 1209NɎn܂ArWA\ŔA̐IA@I]̔wiɂBtX̒nɍL܂LXgْ̈[J^hłڂAJgbN̏@IeƂA[}@CmPeBEX3̖]B́AICꌗ̖ktX͂AgD[[YƂ𒆐SƂtXEIbNꌗ̗̓yɓ悤Ƃ]B 1229NA܂ŒRĂgD[Ỹ7́AɃArWA\R̍UɋAJ^h̒Ǔɋ͂邱ƁAgD[Y̖hqƁA𖾓nƂȂǂBɂAOhbNn̓Ɨ͏IAtX̎xzɓB1229N11ɃgD[YɈْ[RiInquisitionjݒ肳ꂽB ْ[R̒ǂꂽJ^h́AZM[iMontsegurjɓB30l̋Rm150l̕m܂߂Ė500lĘUBJgbNũViS[OvƌĂꂽRB̂ƂevRmcZM[Ƃ`B J^hAڂ̑3ŐGꂽJJ\k쓌ւ悻80LAZM[̓sl[R̘[ɂBtX̒S◣Ă邽߁AArWA\R̐\NԂ̐NUɂS炸ÂƂ܂ŐNUƂĂB W1207m̊Riʐ^Aj̒ɏ邪ƂBݎcĂՁiʐ^Bj́Aŋ߂̒Łi1964N|1976NjAArWA\R̂̂ł͂ȂƂB
1243NɎn܂͍͍ɂ߂BȓΊ˒ɂ܂ʼn^яグ邱ƂłȂ̂B1244N1AɎR̖k̒nD\ŔAΊiʐ^ Cj̍UōԂɌďXɐiłB 1244N3AZM[̗̎sG[=WFE~v͂ƂƂ~邱Ƃ߁A\Rƍ~BJ^M̂ĂΒPȂǕōςށArIȂ̂B wǂ̃J^PerfectiiVʉ߂uSȎҁvj͂M̂Ă邱ƂۂB肩AbARmAmȂǂ̒A26lConsolamentumiԂ߂̋VjJ^ɋA˂邱ƂIB ~̋xԂ̑OɁAl̃J^hM҂RoƂB̎ނ炪J^̔oƂ̂Ǎ̐t`̂ƂɂȂĂB t`̓i`̋䂫Ai`X̃Ibg[E[͐t`ƃJ^̌qƂ2̏B1982NɏołꂽuHoly Blood, Holy GrailikVg[̓@CGX̌Ɛt`jvł̓J^h̎o@Ƃ̓CGX̉ƌv}łƂB 1244N316̒AM̂Ă邱Ƃۂ200lÕJ^hM҂AZM[̓쑤̎ΖʂāApӂꂽt̏Yɐg𓊂B RƊëw̕𐁂ċĂAJ^hBXyC̃CXk_l̃Jo`ҒBƂlbg[NAt`evRmcɂւAVlƂBJ^h͂₪ė@v̐삯ƂȂB̎vz̐Ղ̓Om[VX`ɂoBJ^hɂẴEGbuTCg͐A̓`͐lX̋߂炦Ă܂ȂB J^h́AEEEłł͂ȂB |